Tag Archives: docomomo

Part II: Tropical Modernism in a Multicultural Context at the Docomomo US National Symposium

In PART I we discussed the University of Hawaii at Manoa campus (especially the stunning Jefferson Hall), presentations on traditional architecture to mid-century modernism and Asian influences on the built environment in Hawaii, and the Residences of Wimberly and Cook. For Part II we are hopping back into the Aloha Spirit by discussing the regal Hawaii State Capitol Building, presentations on historic preservation and how Hawaii was influential and integral to international tropical resort design.
hawaii-state-capitol-bldg
HAWAII STATE CAPITOL BUILDING
I have only been to about ten state capitols across the U.S., but the Hawaii State Capitol building is unlike any I have experience. It is a truly welcoming structure, which is something unique among monumental civic structures (looking at you Boston City Hall). The Hawaii State Capitol was designed by Belt, Lemmon & Lo in association with John Carl Warnecke. While design of the building began in 1961, construction didn’t break ground until 1965, and the building was formerly dedicated on March 15, 1969. The Hawaii State Capitol celebrated its 50th anniversary in 2019.

An excerpt from Democracy by Design. The Planning and Development of the Hawaii State Capitol, with text by Don J. Hibbard states it best:

“Monumentally presiding over an eight acre site mostly carpeted by lawn, the Capitol is surrounded by a pool of water, evoking Hawaii’s island situation. The truncated cones of the legislative chambers, clad in cast stone made of crushed lava rock, rise from the reflecting pool, reminiscent of the volcanic origins of the islands. Also rising from the water are forty columns, bereft of capitals, instead flaring out of their crown like coconut palms. Standing almost sixty feet in height, the columns form a peristyle and support the extra-large fourth story, which cantilevers out beyond the columns. Serving as a cornice, the fourth story is distinguished by its open work frieze of pre-cast fins set in groups of eight, recalling the eight major islands of Hawaii. Placed free of the windows, the fins serve as decorative elements as well as sun screens. The recessed second and third floors are suspended from the fourth story, which also serves as the roof of the capital, with the governor and lieutenant governor’s offices in penthouses on top of the roof. Rising above the penthouses, the blue crown of the central rotunda echoes a volcanic crater, a graceful interpretation of the traditional statehouse dome.” (1)

hawaii-state-capitol-building-details
PARADISE PARADIGMS
DeSoto Brown
Kiersten Faulkner

These two presentations were an interesting pair. DeSoto Brown presented in a style reminiscent of informational videos produced in the 1950’s and 1960’s that were designed to encourage travel to the islands of Hawaii by showing the Aloha Spirit and all Hawaii has to offer. All the photos presented were from the archives. It wasn’t until after his presentation that he mentioned a majority of the structures pictured have since been demolished or severely altered. Remember, Hawaii was aggressively built up only since post-World War II!
downtown-honolulu
This made for a great transition into Kiersten Faulkner’s presentation on the threats and challenges of preservation and tropical modernist design – how to preserve architecture from so recent in the past. Turns out the issues (for the most part) mainland preservationist have are the same Hawaii preservationists experience. Similar to Oregon and elsewhere, that 50 year historic threshold causes a lot of havoc at times. What happens when a resource is 46 years of age in integral to our built heritage, but threatened with demolition because, sorry it’s not 5-0 historic! Kiersten also described how there is anger and hurt around some mid-century resources (mainly spiritual structures) because they replaced older structures on the same site. Interestingly enough, Hawaii doesn’t have a leg-up on mainland solutions for the intersection of preservation, sustainability, and climate change. I was a bit surprised when I asked a colleague that worked in the preservation community in Hawaii if they did anything specific to mitigating resources going directly to the landfill from demolition since they were on an island. The full answer was “No.”

DESIGNING PARADISE
Don J. Hibbard
Ron Lindgren

Designing Paradise focused on resort design in post-war Hawaii, specifically how it influenced tropical resort design throughout the world. The design and development of the Mauna Kea Resort and Ed Killingsworth Hawaii resort designs: Halekulani, Kapalua Bay Hotel, Mauna Lani Resort, Ihilani Hotel, and renovation of the Kahala Hilton Hotel were discussed. Don and Ron explained how the distinctive and elegant approaches to resort design seen at Mauna Kea Resort and the others would ultimately set the standards for tropical resort design throughout Hawaii and the world.

The Ed Killingsworth designs discussed were divine. The attention to detail Killingsworth incorporated into his creations was phenomenal to see and learn about. Those concrete spider legs that became a staple of his residential, commercial and resort designs are stunning architectural geometries for the eyes. Killingsworth was a planner for the City and County of Honolulu pre and post-World War II. While his resorts were interesting to learn about, Ron Lindgren discussed at length his residential designs in California.
waikiki-beach-diamond-head
Killingsworth personal residence was breathtaking. If only every house was designed with the level of attention, detail, and space planning that brings the indoors out and vice versa that Killingsworth executed. What caught my attention was how Killingsworth designed the kitchen at his personal residence in California. He had floating wood lower cabinets, which looked more like beautiful pieces of furniture than storage for kitchen-wares. Also, he did not use a backsplash – genius! Behind the floating cabinets with the kitchen sink, a full ceiling-to-floor window was used, including underneath the floating cabinets. This played a trick on the eye, with the abundance of natural light flooding from above and below the cabinets the space looked larger and lighter. Also, why are we SO obsessed with back-splashes and kitchen islands? His designs make the case for neither. His interpretations of lanai living was on full display in his California residence.

The Mauna Kea Resort. Laurance Rockefeller was the developer that brought the world to Kauna’oa beach, and ushered in a new era of tourism to Hawaii. The Mauna Kea Resort opened in the summer of 1965, and was designed by SOM in the most sophisticated mid-century style. Concrete has never looked as elegant as it disappears into the surrounding natural landscapes. It was the first resort along the coastline of Hawaii’s Big Island. Mauna Kea Resort also features a prominent art and artifacts collection. The contributions to the Big Island that Rockefeller enabled in the mid-century are still thriving today.
IBM-building-honolulu
Tropical Modernism in a Multicultural Context at the Docomomo US National Symposium was a delight to experience. The closing reception was at the Ossipoff designed IBM building (1962). Talk about an iconic Honolulu mid-century building. The exterior façade grille is retro yet timeless architectural elegance. And, it was fitting to have the opening and closing receptions at two distinct mid-century buildings in Honolulu designed by one of the most prolific architect’s in Hawaii.

I wouldn’t be able to end this two part blog without mentioning the hotel that hosted several social events, part of the symposium programming: the Surfjack. From the beautiful lanai, delicious restaurant with fantastic mai tai’s, to the quaint yet stylish rooms, the POOL, and welcoming staff. The Surfjack felt like a home away from home in the heart of downtown Waikiki.

For designers, architects, planners, preservationists, and those generally interested in mid-century design, Docomomo US National Symposium is a MUST on your list of mid-century focused events.
surf-jack-hotel

Written by Kate Kearney, Associate.

1. The Hawaii State Foundation on Culture and the Arts in accordance with the recommendation of The Task Force to Plan and Coordinate the Celebration of the Fiftieth Anniversary of the Hawaii State Capitol. Democracy by Design. The Planning and Development of the Hawaii State Capitol, by Don. J. Hibbard. Honolulu, 2019.

PART I: Tropical Modernism in a Multicultural Context at the Docomomo US National Symposium

Tropical Modernism was showcased, explored, and celebrated at the sixth annual Docomomo US National Symposium in late September 2019. Docomomo US/Hawaii chapter hosted, and as the current Docomomo US/Oregon chapter president I had the opportunity to experience all things tropical and modern in Oahu, Hawaii.

Honolulu (2)-pmapdx

For those unfamiliar with the mouthful that is Docomomo (documentation for the conservation of the modern movement), it’s a national (technically international) non-profit dedicated to the preservation of modern architecture, landscape and design. At the Oregon chapter we take this mission a bit further by including art from the core era of modernism and one of the most controversial architectural movements: post modernism. But let’s get back to the oasis that is Oahu. First, if you have the opportunity to visit this island – DO IT. It is a multicultural, dense cosmopolitan city yet rural surf-town, absolute food heaven, post-war architectural wonderland where tropical resort design began, all rolled into one island that has weather far superior than what we ever get in the state of Oregon. Why do we all live in the cold and rain?!

The symposium kicked-off with a welcome reception at the Outrigger Canoe Club. The building is situated right along the Waikiki coast and was designed by Vladimir Ossipoff in 1941. Ossipoff had a prolific Honolulu-based firm, Ossipoff Snyder Architects. A common theme I was unware would take a central role throughout the symposium was about tropical outdoor/indoor living, or better known as lanai.

honolulu-beach

UNIVERSITY OF HAWAII AT MANOA
University of Hawaii at Manoa hosted the first day of symposium presentations at Jefferson Hall. While there are several mid-century buildings across the campus, Jefferson Hall is an architectural gem among them. Completed in 1963 and designed by Chinese-American architect I.M. Pei with Young & Henderson. Jefferson Hall was the last building constructed of the East-West Center (EWC) campus. The EWC helped put Hawaii on an international stage, connecting Asia and the West. Jefferson Hall in particular “combines the austere symmetry of the New Formalism with hints of Chinese traditional architecture to convey the links between Asia and the West envisioned by the center’s multiple champions and founders.” (1.)

HAWAII OVERVIEW – from traditional architecture to mid-century modernism
Glenn Mason
Graham Hart

Bit perplexed that native Hawaiian architecture was breezed over and barely mentioned. The presentation began with thatched houses, then quickly jumped to the first Western-style frame houses being shipped to Hawaii in the 1820s. These were the type of structures the Missionaries were accustomed to. From there we learned that basalt quarries were developed in the 1880s, and the California Gold Rush really opened up west coast trade to Hawaii. For the first time Douglas Fir was shipped from the mainland to Hawaii. Mason then explained that while Hawaii had designers, they did not have architects, but architects from Australia or the mainland came to Hawaii and contributed to the beaux-arts and neo-classical styled structures. It wasn’t until the early 1900’s that a regional style began to express itself in Hawaii, and across the mainland. Hawaii regional style elements include: double pitched roof, lanai, local materials, and an overhang roof.

Towards the end of the 1930s change thinking happens and international style references begins to be expressed in architecture. Hawaii sees an influx of younger architects from Europe that were schooled in modernist design. The late 1930s had a stream of construction on military bases (several designed by Albert Kahns office), but by the time of WWII, 99% of architects on the island went to work for the military. From the 1930s through the 1960s there is a shift in the architecture vocabulary in Hawaii. It begins with regional style with a hint of modern, then modern used to reinterpret regionalism. Modern architects of note in Hawaii from that era:

Vladimir Ossipoff
Peter Wimberly
Lemmon, Freeth, Haines, and Jones
Edwim Bauer
Alfred Preis
Johnson & Perkins

The shift in the architecture vocabulary in Hawaii continues from the 1940s through the 1970s. Now we begin to see the environmental influences on modernism, even though rural landscapes are being transformed into cosmopolitan centers with smaller, steep, tight sites or housing. Materials used for modern design now includes concrete, cast concrete, lava rock, coral, local woods, and aggregates. Modern architecture in Hawaii also embraces the natural environment. This is most reflective in architect’s obsessions with lanai. This obsession found its way from residential homes to large developments. The East-West Center (1962-1963) at the University of Hawaii Manoa, designed by I.M. Pei, is a phenomenal example of a monumental, institutional piece of architecture that embraced the lanai.

Jefferson-Hall-001

ASIAN INFLUENCES
Alison Chiu and Alissa Carson
Lorraine Minatoishi
Luca Guido

This group of presentations focused on different facets of Asian influences and how the contributions were interwoven in post-war architectural design throughout Hawaii. Lorraine Minatoishi focused on Japanese temple architecture influence of modern design post-war. There were distinct temple styles developed throughout their history in Hawaii:

Japanese Traditional Style (late 1800s – early 1900s)
Plantation Style (late 1800s – early 1900s)
Hawaii Eclectic Style (early 1900s – 1950s)
East-West Style (1918 – 1950s)
Post-War Modernism (led by second-generation Japanese architect Niser)
Post-War Traditional

Luca’s presentation took it a step further by discussing an obscure architect from the mid-century modern era, Bruce Goff, and how he also influenced local architects to Hawaii. I had not heard of Bruce Goff like most, but Luca Guido explained why this figure in the realm of modernism was obscured until now.

RESIDENCES OF WIMBERLY AND COOK
Following presentations at the University of Hawaii and a self-guided walking tour of other mid-century campus resources, I chose to attend the Residences of Wimberly & Cook Tour. Pete Wimberly of Wimberly & Cook designed two residences situated above the Manoa Valley. Wimberly designed some of the most iconic mid-century modern buildings in Hawaii. Wimberly came to Hawaii in 1940, and post-war his career flourished. His designs embodied tropical modernism, spaces that blurred indoor and outdoor living. The residential designs we toured both featured indoor/outdoor living, natural cross-ventilation, elegant interior details and finishes, and a smart use of natural light. However, they were completely different in essence, aesthetic, style, and state.
Cook-Residence-PMAPDX
The Japanese style pavilion house was like walking into a meticulously cared-for time capsule. There wasn’t even dust on the book shelves that displayed artifacts collected and arranged by the original homeowner! However, there were a few signs of wear-and-tear on the interior Japanese style floor mats, kitchen cabinets along their frames, and slight dry-rot peppered across the original wood deck. Otherwise the home was pristinely maintained. Wimberly’s private residence across the street was a different story.

Wimberly’s private residence was constructed in 1945. This is an insane date for residential construction due to World-War II ending the same year, and the majority of architects/contractors in Oahu were working on military projects. With the Japanese style pavilion home, you enter by walking down slightly winding stone steps. With Wimberly’s private residence, you enter by climbing up stone steps that deliver visitors to a small landing, and then up more exterior stairs. The second set of stairs (wood planks suspended by cables) makes for a swoon-worthy entry sequence that looks like something Dwell or Architectural Digest would gobble up for a feature article.
Wimberly-Residence-PMAPDX
From the now faded red door, redish-pink painted wood paneled ceilings, decorative animal sculptures situated within the header above the door that leads from the dining area into the kitchen, to ornate light fixtures and various metal finishes throughout the space, Wimberly’s private residence utilized design elements that reflected the multicultural diversity of Hawaii. The residence is also quintessential mid-century design: natural cross-ventilation, sliding wall panels to completely open up or section off the main-floor living, dining and lounge areas, and a technological savvy (for its time) kitchen. From the perspective of how we design kitchens today, it is real sad and small, save for the to-die-for view of the lush tropical garden from the kitchen window over the sink.

Wimberley’s private residence also showed signs of being well lived-in, yet not maintained with any desired vigor. The wood framed windows on either side of the structure are rotting like the planks along the entry façade deck, and there are several cracked panes of window glass. Structural settling has made itself known, and the kitchen is retro in a manner no one would want for daily use. Most of the interior painted walls or ceilings have faded into softer hues of their original bold colors. And, when we visited, it looked as though someone was living there, yet possibly setting up an estate sale for interior items. There were some true mid-century interior design gems scattered in the clutter piled up from the floor I wish I could have packed in my suitcase for the return trip.

Hope you enjoyed PART I: Tropical Modernism in a Multicultural Context at the Docomomo US National Symposium! In Part II we will discuss the Hawaii State Capitol, and presentations on Historic Preservation in Hawaii and Tropical Resort Design.

Written by Kate Kearney, Associate.

1. Shen, Haigo and Irene. Tropical Modernism At University of Hawaii At Manoa. Docomomo US National Symposium, Oahu, Hawaii, September 2019.

PM DOCO OR Award Announcement

2019 Modernism in America Awards

DOCOUS-Modernism-In-America-2019-Award

“Not all preservation advocacy efforts result in a positive outcome, but these efforts would never happen in the first place without one person carrying the banner, holding the megaphone, taking the lead, and Peter has exhibited that strongly in this case, and throughout his career.”
– Gunny Harboe, Docomomo US Director

Via DOCOMOMO US
An Advocacy Award of Excellence is given to Peter Meijer, AIA, NCARB, for his leadership and advocacy work related to the Portland Public Service Building (the Portland Building). As the founding President of DOCOMOMO US/Oregon, Peter and his architectural practice Peter Meijer Architect, PC (PMA) played a pivotal role in speaking up and advocating for the sensitive preservation of the Postmodern icon, designed by Michael Graves and completed in 1982.

In 2011, PMA wrote the nomination to add the building to the National Register of Historic Places, a serious undertaking, without being contracted to do so. Shortly thereafter the city began to consider making improvements after years of deferred maintenance and chose to move forward with a reconstruction plan that disregarded the Secretary of the Interior’s Standards.

Despite opposition from PMA, local and national advocates, and a letter from the National Park Service stating the building would be “de-listed” from the National Register, the Portland Landmarks Commission nevertheless voted to approve the reconstruction plan. Faced with significant alteration of arguably Portland’s most important architectural icon, Peter pushed forward individually and appealed the decision. Portland City Council denied the appeal, essentially ending the effort. Peter remained dedicated to the cause throughout the entire process, despite substantial local professional risk.

Although the fight is now over, DOCOMOMO US/Oregon has not let the story go out of the headlines, continuing to document the ongoing dismantling of the Portland Building’s façade.

For the full list of 2019 MODERNISM IN AMERICA award winners, please visit DOCOMOMO US.